West Bengal Vote Count Marred by Allegations of Power Cuts and Unauthorized Access to EVM Strongrooms
The vote counting process in West Bengal has descended into a war of credibility, with the Trinamool Congress levelling serious allegations of electoral sabotage. Party leaders, including MP Mahua Moitra and Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, have pointed to a 2-minute-16-second power failure and the disabling of CCTV cameras at strongrooms in Sreerampur, Krishnanagar, Ausgram, and Khudiram Anushilan Kendra in Kolkata. They allege these outages allowed BJP-linked vehicles to enter the Bhabanipur counting centre compound—actions they claim were deliberately timed to obstruct surveillance. TMC workers have been instructed to remain vigilant, document irregularities, and file formal complaints, underscoring the party’s belief that the election’s integrity is under threat.
The BJP has dismissed the allegations as theatrical and politically motivated. Spokespersons Sajal Ghosh and Charles Nandy accused Mamata Banerjee of preparing a narrative of electoral theft in advance of her expected defeat, calling the claims 'hilarious' and pre-scripted. The party denies any of its representatives entered restricted areas, emphasizing that access to strongrooms is strictly controlled and requires EC clearance. They argue the TMC, with a history of electoral malpractice, is attempting to delegitimize the outcome before the final results are declared.
The Election Commission of India has firmly rejected all accusations, stating that CCTV systems operated without interruption and that standard three-tier security—comprising CAPF, Armed Police, and State Police—was in place across all centres. State Chief Electoral Officer Manoj Kumar Agarwal clarified that while power supply falls under the state’s jurisdiction, backup generators were available and deployed as needed. Regarding the BJP-flagged vehicle near Bhabanipur, the EC confirmed it was inspected and found non-objectionable, having merely passed along Harish Mukherjee Road. However, the Commission’s explanation for officials accessing the Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose Indoor Stadium strongroom during a power cut—to sort postal ballots by torchlight—has drawn scepticism from TMC, which questions why access was permitted without party representatives present.
The crisis in confidence predates the counting process. On April 30, Mamata Banerjee staged a four-hour protest outside the Bhabanipur strongroom, alleging unauthorized EVM handling, while BJP workers simultaneously blocked a TMC vehicle they claimed carried duplicate EVMs for ballot swapping. These parallel incidents reflect a profound mutual suspicion between the two parties. Protests have since spread to Asansol and Barasat, with more claims of surveillance blackouts. Whether or not these allegations hold technical merit, the perception of vulnerability in the counting process threatens public trust in the electoral system. Looking ahead, the situation underscores the urgent need for real-time, transparent audit mechanisms and independent oversight in high-stakes elections—particularly in politically volatile states like West Bengal, where the margin between victory and defeat can hinge as much on perception as on vote counts.